The World Health Organization’s 1955 assault on malaria carrying mosquitoes using the insecticide DDT almost succeeded in wiping out the most pernicious infectious disease in human history. Here, we consider a counterfactual science scenario: What if DDT had been a little faster, thereby combatting the inevitable development of resistance to the compound, a biological response ultimately doomed worldwide malaria eradication. A faster-acting difluoro DDT congener, DFDT, was developed in Germany during World War II but its purported superior performance against insects and reduced toxicity to mammals compared to DDT were dismissed by Allied military inspectors in 1945. DFDT was never again manufactured. We aimed to establish whether a broad-spectrum insecticide, DFDT, is hiding in plain view. Here, we show the efficacy of amorphous and crystalline forms of DFDT and a mono-fluorinated chiral congener, MFDT, all previously unknown, against Drosophila as well as Anopheles and Aedes mosquitoes. We compared the lethality of two crystalline polymorphs of DFDT, four crystals of chiral MFDT (racemic and resolved), as well as the respective persistent amorphous solids. Our results demonstrate that crystalline DFDT and MFDT kill faster than DDT, and their amorphous forms were even faster, which is essential for mitigating vector resistance. We also demonstrate an unambiguous inverse relationship between lethality and thermodynamic stability of solid forms, which suggests a crystal engineering strategy for improving the efficacy of known insecticides by tailoring crystal form. We anticipate that the fluorinated congeners, properly evaluated, may be effective in the battle against insect-borne diseases.